Carbon monoxide has no color, no smell, and no taste — and your furnace is one of the most common sources of it in a home. When a gas furnace operates correctly, combustion gases vent safely outside. When something goes wrong, those gases can enter your living space without any warning you’d notice on your own.
Knowing how to tell if a furnace is causing carbon monoxide — and acting on it — is one of the more important things a homeowner can understand as the heating season gets underway.
What Causes a Furnace to Put Out Carbon Monoxide?
Carbon monoxide forms during incomplete combustion — when fuel doesn’t burn fully. In a properly functioning gas furnace, that process happens safely and the byproducts exit through the flue. A few specific failures can disrupt that:
A Cracked Heat Exchanger
The heat exchanger is a sealed metal chamber inside the furnace that separates combustion gases from the air circulating through your home. Over time — especially on older systems — it can develop cracks. When it does, combustion gases including carbon monoxide can mix with the air the blower distributes throughout the house.
A cracked heat exchanger is invisible from the outside and can only be identified through professional inspection. It’s one of the primary reasons annual furnace tune-ups matter.
Blocked or Backdrafting Flue
The flue carries combustion gases out of the home. If it becomes blocked — by a bird’s nest, debris, ice, or a structural issue — those gases have nowhere to go and can back up into the living space. Backdrafting can also occur due to pressure imbalances in the home, such as powerful exhaust fans competing with the furnace for air.
Incomplete Combustion
If the furnace isn’t getting adequate airflow, or if the burners are dirty or misaligned, fuel won’t burn completely — and incomplete combustion produces higher levels of carbon monoxide. A clogged air filter or dirty burners can both contribute.
How to Tell If a Furnace Is Causing Carbon Monoxide
The most reliable way to tell if a furnace is causing carbon monoxide is a functioning CO detector. That’s the bottom line. But there are other indicators worth knowing.
Physical Symptoms in the Home
CO poisoning symptoms often feel like flu without a fever. If multiple people in the home experience headaches, dizziness, nausea, or unusual fatigue — particularly when the heat is running — and feel better when they leave the house, carbon monoxide exposure should be suspected immediately. Pets may show similar symptoms first, since they’re lower to the ground and have faster respiratory rates.
What the Flame Can Tell You
On a gas furnace, a healthy burner flame should be steady and blue. A yellow or orange flame indicates incomplete combustion — the fuel isn’t burning cleanly, and carbon monoxide production is higher. If you can safely view the flame through the furnace’s observation window and it looks yellow or flickering, call a technician before running the system again.
Soot or Excessive Condensation
Black soot near the furnace, or unusual condensation on windows when the heat runs, can both signal combustion problems. These aren’t definitive proof of CO, but they warrant investigation.
How Can I Detect Carbon Monoxide Emissions From My Home Furnace?
You can’t detect CO without a detector. The gas is completely undetectable by human senses at dangerous levels, which is what makes it so hazardous. Every home with a gas furnace should have working carbon monoxide detectors. For a broader seasonal overview — including what to check when firing up your furnace for the first time each fall — see our Carbon Monoxide Safety + Fall Furnace Start-Up Checklist for Bucks County Homes.
Where Should Carbon Monoxide Detectors Be Placed Near a Furnace?
The CDC and CPSC recommend placing CO detectors on every level of the home, including the basement. Key placement guidelines:
- Within 10 feet of each sleeping area, so the alarm can wake occupants
- On each floor of the home, including the basement near the furnace
- Away from windows, doors, and vents that could dilute readings
- Not directly above or beside the furnace — a few feet away is appropriate
CO detectors have a lifespan of 5 to 7 years. Check the manufacture date on yours — if it’s past that window, replace it. A functioning detector is the only reliable early warning system for a furnace CO problem.
Emergency Steps If Carbon Monoxide Is Detected Near a Furnace
If your CO detector alarms — or if you suspect carbon monoxide exposure based on symptoms — treat it as an emergency:
- Get out: Get everyone out of the house immediately, including pets
- Don’t linger: Do not stop to open windows or investigate — leave first
- Call 911 from outside: Firefighters carry CO meters and can assess the situation safely
- Stay out: Do not re-enter until emergency responders have cleared the building
- Call a technician: Call your HVAC company to inspect the furnace before it runs again
Never silence the alarm and go back to sleep assuming it’s a false alarm. If the detector is alarming, take it seriously.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my furnace leak carbon monoxide even if it’s off?
In most cases, no. CO from a furnace is produced during combustion — when the system is actively burning gas. A furnace that’s powered off isn’t producing combustion gases. However, if your home has other gas appliances (water heater, gas range, dryer), CO can come from those sources even when the furnace isn’t running.
What can falsely set off a carbon monoxide detector?
True false alarms from quality CO detectors are uncommon, but some triggers include: the detector reaching the end of its service life, certain chemical fumes (paint, solvents, cleaning products), or a detector placed too close to a gas appliance where trace combustion gases are normal during startup. If your alarm goes off repeatedly without a clear source, have the home inspected rather than assuming the detector is faulty.
What kind of professional inspects furnaces for carbon monoxide leaks near you?
A NATE-certified HVAC technician is the right professional for a furnace CO inspection. They have the equipment to check combustion efficiency, inspect the heat exchanger, test flue draft, and measure CO levels in the air supply. Homeowners in Doylestown, Warrington, Blue Bell, North Wales, and surrounding Bucks and Montgomery County communities can call TCS for this service — it’s part of what a professional tune-up covers.
Don’t Wait on This One
If you haven’t had your furnace inspected this season, how to tell if a furnace is causing carbon monoxide is less important than simply making sure it isn’t. A professional inspection addresses the root causes — cracked heat exchangers, dirty burners, flue obstructions — before they become an emergency.
TCS Heating and Air Conditioning has been inspecting and servicing furnaces across Bucks and Montgomery counties since 1976. According to the CDC, carbon monoxide poisoning causes more than 400 unintentional non-fire-related deaths in the U.S. each year — and most of them are preventable.
Ready to have your furnace inspected? The team at TCS Heating and Air Conditioning is here to help homeowners across Bucks and Montgomery counties. Give us a call at (215) 323-5330 or reach out through our contact page to schedule service or get your questions answered.